A West Village storefront by designer Donna Karan is suing its neighbor for its alleged position in creating and allowing a rat infestation so extreme that it has employees members fearing for his or her security.
City Zen filed a lawsuit in New York Supreme Court docket towards the proprietor of the neighboring property, an empty lot related to William Gottlieb Actual Property, alleging harm to its enterprise operations and posing a well being disaster. The defendant disputes the accusations.
The properties in query are 705 Greenwich Road, the place City Zen has its retailer, and 703 Greenwich Road, a vacant lot linked to William Gottlieb Actual Property.
The designer based City Zen in 2007 to assist her cultural preservation nonprofit of the identical identify. The model, which additionally has areas within the Hamptons and Palm Seashore, has high-end attire, equipment and residential furnishings, with cashmere sweatpants going for $1,395 and a suede romper advertised at $3,495.
City Zen alleges that the rat downside started in 2024, when a downed tree was eliminated however its stump remained. That, together with rubble and particles, created “burrowing channels” that allowed rats to entry the City Zen property, in accordance with the shop. A dumpster on the vacant lot created “a persistent and repeatedly replenished meals supply” for rodents, in accordance with the grievance.
The model claims the infestation has precipitated “reputational hurt, lack of clientele, and monetary harm” after the shop needed to cancel occasions and enterprise actions because of the presence of rats on the property.
The shop has additionally mentioned the infestation is a “menace to human life and well being,” because it exposes these within the retailer to ailments, together with hantavirus.
“Each worker, shopper, visitor, and member of the general public who enters the Premises is in danger,” City Zen mentioned in its grievance.
The LLC that owns the neighboring vacant lot, 703 Greenwich Road, LLC, denied the claims, telling The Actual Deal they had been “spurious” and the property has been well-maintained for half a century.
“We now have persistently retained extermination companies for this website for years and whereas we’ve got solely lately been made conscious of complaints suggesting that further extermination companies could also be wanted, we take such issues significantly,” a consultant for the LLC mentioned in an announcement. “Up to now, no points had been delivered to our consideration in a fashion that indicated the necessity for this stage of intervention.”
The property proprietor mentioned it will consider the scenario and rent further assist as wanted, however they might not be at fault for any vermin points. A neighboring retail property or the numerous eateries within the space may very well be accountable.
“We strongly encourage the tenant to completely consider their very own area, together with any such situations, to make sure that they aren’t contributing to or facilitating this concern,” the consultant mentioned in an announcement. “We’re upset that the neighboring tenant selected to pursue litigation quite than to have interaction with us in good religion to deal with their issues immediately.”
The LLC is related to William Gottlieb Actual Property, the eponymous agency of a prolific downtown property proprietor who compiled an expansive portfolio earlier than his loss of life in 1999 at 64. He purchased greater than 100 properties, the New York Times reported, most of them within the Meatpacking District and the far west facet of the Village, however not often bought. His sister, Mollie Bender, took over the enterprise until her death in 2007, in accordance with amNY.
Gottlieb bought 703 Greenwich Road in 1966, in accordance with metropolis data. Bender and Gottlieb’s property transferred the property to an LLC in 2006.
An legal professional for City Zen didn’t instantly reply to a request for remark.
Learn extra
Designer sues insurance companies’ fraud claim to skip $38M judgment
The next generation of retail brokerages
Louis Vuitton replacing Fifth Ave flagship with taller version
