My colleague Kathryn Brenzel wrote an intriguing article in regards to the Meatpacking District RFP, through which town sought an “rising developer” however didn’t select one.
As a substitute, the Financial Improvement Company chosen a bid by Douglaston Improvement — a really skilled agency — and “rising developer” David Himmel, a former COO on the huge actual property firm Jamestown and scion of a outstanding actual property household.
Alicia Glen, the previous deputy mayor, mentioned as a feminist she discovered the choice “appalling and disgraceful.”
Glen is completely proper that this was a missed alternative for town to assist a feminine developer. Nevertheless it’s price mentioning that town had one other precedence: to create as a lot reasonably priced housing as potential. For that, it tapped a proposal from an skilled group with ample entry to capital.
Town and state usually have varied objectives for his or her tasks — low hire, group advantages, MWBE companies, union labor and extra. Some are at odds with one another, and it’s unimaginable to meet all of them whereas additionally selecting a viable bid. The Meatpacking RFP for the previous Gansevoort Meat Market web site was a traditional instance.
One actual property skilled instructed me quickly after the RFP was issued that it regarded like a difficult undertaking, due to the affordability required and different components, though town was providing a free 99-year lease for the land.
The successful bid will put aside as much as 55 p.c of the residences as reasonably priced and use no subsidy past the usual 485x, which requires excessive wages for development staff. And it comes from Jeff Levine’s Douglaston, which has 40 years of expertise, and the well-credentialed Himmel.
Nothing in improvement is assured, however Douglaston and Himmel are extra probably to have the ability to increase the mandatory capital and produce the undertaking to fruition than a much less skilled, much less related builder, and possibly supply extra affordability, too.
Himmel clearly doesn’t appear to be an rising developer. And it’s not nice optics that EDC president and CEO Andrew Kimball additionally labored at Jamestown. However the households who win housing lotteries for the reasonably priced models should not going to care.
What we’re enthusiastic about: The place will Andrew Kimball go when Zohran Mamdani turns into mayor? Whom will Mamdani choose to run the Financial Improvement Company? Ship ideas to eengquist@therealdeal.com.
A factor we’ve discovered: Underneath a law simply signed by Gov. Kathy Hochul, landlords can not make a revenue on a bounced-check price handed on to a tenant. There may be one exception: A landlord can nonetheless cost no less than $20, even when the financial institution price is lower than that quantity.
Elsewhere…
Final week, we had been enthusiastic about how Blackstone could possibly be taking a heavy loss on a $1.8 billion portfolio of senior housing, an asset class experiencing a “sturdy rebound,” in accordance with Baker Tilly, and the inhabitants is getting old.
A reader responded by stating three components that may make senior housing difficult to function:
- It has plenty of move-outs (together with deaths)
- In recessions or different instances when it’s exhausting for seniors to promote their properties, fewer can afford to maneuver into senior housing
- Persons are staying of their properties longer than they used to, partly due to property tax reductions, and thus shifting into senior housing later, which implies shorter stays
One factor I do know from expertise is that even when shifting into senior housing (or a doorman constructing) makes good sense, many older individuals will stay in homes and communities not conducive to getting old in place. However that has all the time been true.
Closing time
Residential: The highest residential deal recorded Tuesday was $13 million for a four-bedroom co-op at 1050 Fifth Avenue in Carnegie Hill. Anne Z Easton with Douglas Elliman had the listing.
Industrial: The highest business deal recorded was $160 million for 346 Madison Avenue and 11 East 44th Street close to Grand Central Terminal. Claudio Del Vecchio offered the 2 properties to SL Inexperienced.
New to the Market: The very best worth for a residential property hitting the market was $12.25 million for a 3,161-square-foot condominium unit at The Westbury, 15 East 69th Road in Lenox Hill. Anthony Pike of Douglas Elliman has the itemizing.
Breaking Floor: The most important new constructing allow filed was for a proposed 37,360-square-foot, 12-story, 48-unit residential undertaking at 2790 Creston Avenue in Fordham. Anthony Ng filed the allow on behalf of Lengthy G Lin.
— Matthew Elo
