This story offers you a peek on the content material coming to our new platform, TRD Coverage Professional. Signal as much as get early entry here.
A city-controlled land financial institution might quickly purchase tax-delinquent properties and redevelop a few of these parcels into inexpensive housing.
That’s the concept behind 4 Metropolis Council payments accredited with little fanfare in late January which might be poised to rework the town’s contentious tax lien sale, transferring it away from the present mannequin of promoting liens to a non-public belief that fees homeowners hefty curiosity and may transfer to foreclose.
Underneath the laws, a New York Metropolis Land Belief would have the authority to amass tax liens from the town and switch these properties to companions who would rehabilitate distressed or vacant parcels into income-restricted housing, whereas persevering with to gather municipal arrears. Earlier than officers can get began on any of that work, nonetheless, the town should apply for authorization from the New York State City Growth Corp. and develop particular guidelines to control the land financial institution.
“We’re making an attempt so as to add to our toolbox to keep up and produce inexpensive housing,” mentioned Council member Gale Brewer, who sponsored a invoice to ascertain the land financial institution. “How can we be revolutionary in regards to the lien sale, as a substitute of getting properties simply go to the best bidder?”
The payments are poised to develop into regulation by March, and crucially, they’ve the backing of the Mamdani administration. Matt Rauschenbach, a spokesperson for the mayor, instructed The Actual Deal that the administration seems ahead to implementing the land financial institution payments “to maintain New Yorkers secure, secure and of their properties.”
The Metropolis Council initially handed the bundle of payments in December, however former Mayor Eric Adams vetoed the laws out of concern that it might cut back the town’s assortment of arrears. On Jan. 29, a Council supermajority overrode these vetoes.
Brewer’s invoice, which she mentioned would allow the town to focus on “possible dozens not hundreds” of properties to rehabilitate, creates a seven-member board of administrators to manage the land financial institution. It might be made up of appointees by Mayor Mamdani, the commissioners of the town’s housing and finance departments and Council Speaker Julie Menin.
Enormous questions stay unresolved, nonetheless, about how such a land financial institution would perform, and if the brand new system would lead to considerably totally different outcomes for property homeowners.
“There’s nonetheless some uncertainty right here about what the method will change,” mentioned Rachel Geballe, an legal professional with Brooklyn Authorized Providers and a member of the Coalition for Reasonably priced Houses, which is made up of greater than 30 housing and group organizations that advocate for tax lien sale reform. “This is step one in an extended journey,” she added.
For starters, appointees to the board should create bylaws on how the land financial institution would purchase and prioritize properties — this months-long course of would come with a public listening to to tell these guidelines — after which the board should submit an software to the City Growth Corp. for permission to create the land financial institution. As soon as the applying is with the state-run company, it’ll take as much as two months to course of, however approval is all however assured.
The City Growth Corp. has solely as soon as denied an software for a land financial institution, and that was as a consequence of a jurisdiction squabble as a result of a county and a metropolis inside it submitted competing land financial institution purposes, mentioned Emily Mijatovic, a spokesperson for the Empire State Growth Corp., which oversees City Growth Corp.
State push
The passage of the town laws comes simply as Gov. Kathy Hochul is pushing to increase using land banks as a device to create and protect inexpensive housing all through the state. As a part of her proposed funds, Hochul plans to extend the cap on the variety of land banks that may be established in New York from 35 to 45 — there are at the moment 31 land banks throughout the state, together with in Albany, Rochester and Syracuse. Thus far, none exist within the 5 boroughs.
Information from the New York Land Financial institution Affiliation, a company based in 2015 to assist the state’s land banks, discovered that the land banks have returned $135 million in assessed worth to native tax rolls during the last 13 years. That features rehabilitating 3,231 properties, the affiliation mentioned.
The Hochul administration has made $170 million accessible to assist land banks within the state since 2023. Metropolis lawmakers have individually sought to create a metropolis land financial institution in earlier years, however they in the end weren’t in a position to drum up sufficient assist.
4 payments towards tax lien reform
Again in 2024 the Metropolis Council gave the Division of Finance permission to carry an annual tax lien sale through 2028. A tax lien public sale doesn’t should happen every year — the mayor can postpone a sale and has a number of instances — however after they do, they’ll have new necessities geared towards reforming the system because of the bundle of council laws.
Past Brewer’s invoice to ascertain the land financial institution, one other invoice, sponsored by former Metropolis Council Speaker Adrienne Adams, formally authorizes the town to promote tax liens to a metropolis land financial institution throughout any future gross sales. It additionally requires that any purchaser of a tax lien on a one- to three-unit residential property that’s occupied by the proprietor can not foreclose upon that lien till at the very least one yr has handed after the sale and the worth of the lien reaches both 15% of the property worth or $70,000, whichever is the lesser quantity.
Jennifer Polovetsky, companion at Duane Morris, who labored within the metropolis’s regulation division through the Giuliani administration dealing with tax lien gross sales and in rem foreclosures, mentioned she’s happy with the brand new protections for householders, and that the invoice differentiates extra between owner-occupied housing and landlords who personal multi-family rental buildings.
“To take folks’s properties away for tax liens which might be minimal, I believe, is unfair, on the identical time, all people has to pay their taxes,” mentioned Polovetsky. “It’s a really troublesome balancing act.”
To that finish, a invoice sponsored by Council member Sandy Nurse requires future tax lien purchases to make “greatest efforts” to switch these liens to the town land financial institution “upon sure triggering occasions.” That features any tax liens being bought to the town’s NYCTL 1998-2 Belief, sometimes called the graveyard belief. The belief warehouses the riskiest metropolis liens, and at the moment holds 3,902 tax liens, in line with Division of Finance knowledge obtained by The Actual Deal.
As of 2025, the town’s tax lien trusts include 7,270 liens. That features 3,468 liens on one, two or three-family properties, 2,452 on business properties and 1,355 on multi-family parcels, in line with the DOF knowledge. DOF spokesperson Ryan Lavis mentioned the company has not launched a listing of eligible properties for the following lien sale, which hasn’t been scheduled but.
One other invoice sponsored by Nurse additionally requires the DOF to submit annual experiences on properties with chronically unresolved liens — these excellent for 36 or extra months after being bought.
A controversial program
The present tax lien sale course of, established below the Giuliani administration in 1996, has confronted criticism nearly since its creation for opening up property homeowners to predatory debt collectors. The system additionally has a status for being opaque and a beast to navigate.
The town provides a parcel to the tax lien sale record when its proprietor has long-overdue property taxes or water and sewer payments. The debt is bought to a certified purchaser, normally the Financial institution of New York Mellon and their servicer firms, MTAG Providers, LLC and Tower Capital Administration (Mellon, MTAG and Tower Capital didn’t return requests for touch upon the payments). If the proprietor can’t pay their arrears, plus amassed curiosity, the corporations foreclose on the property.
Underneath the brand new mannequin, the land financial institution and its companions might tackle a few of these duties, however maybe the largest unanswered query is: how will this be financed? As written, the council payments don’t establish a particular funding mechanism for the land financial institution, although Hochul’s assist might assist. It’s additionally unclear which metropolis company would oversee and workers the entity, and who would companion with the town to redevelop properties below its management. Nonprofit group land trusts are one such companion the council is exploring, and for which grass-roots group and housing teams are pushing.
All these lingering questions have the true property business feeling cautious.
Dev Awasthi, vice chairman of presidency affairs on the Actual Property Board of New York, famous that land banks will be profitable in producing housing, however that the town should present the brand new entity with the assets it wants within the upcoming funds — a tall order given the town’s multi-billion greenback funds chasm.
Ann Korchak, board president of the Small Property House owners of New York, went additional and known as the prospect of a metropolis land financial institution “very troubling.”
“To my thoughts, it’s one other alternative to create a COPA-like state of affairs to swoop in and take over distressed properties,” mentioned Korchak, referring to the Community Opportunity to Purchase Act. The controversial Metropolis Council invoice would have given city-approved nonprofits, in addition to joint ventures with for-profit firms, the primary alternative to buy sure distressed multifamily buildings, or these with soon-to-expire affordability necessities.
“We’re watching this very carefully,” added Korchak.
Learn extra
The Daily Dirt: Bracing for the lien sale
Without enough Council override votes, COPA appears dead
The Daily Dirt: Here’s a cheatsheet on J-51, environmental reform proposals
