Fannie Mae says it’s seeing fewer circumstances of multifamily mortgage fraud following a years-long crackdown, a discovering that stunned some market watchers who say misconduct could also be shifting elsewhere fairly than disappearing.
The federal government-supported mortgage big reported that ideas and investigations into multifamily fraud have fallen to 12-month lows, based on {a partially} redacted evaluation revealed by its regulator, the Federal Housing Finance Company.
The decline follows a pointy surge in reported exercise only a 12 months earlier. Fannie mentioned it obtained a flood of ideas associated to multifamily mortgage fraud in 2024, prompting 193 investigations, up from 14 in 2022. The company confirmed fraud in 87 circumstances final 12 months, in contrast with simply three two years earlier.
Fannie mentioned these numbers at the moment are trending down, noting it didn’t discover any potential fraud in its pattern of 44 high-risk loans between September 2024 and January 2025. As of July 2025, multifamily mortgage fraud ideas and investigations at Fannie had been at their lowest ranges in a 12 months.
The findings had been a part of an evaluation by the FHFA, that examined Fannie’s allowance for mortgage losses, or the amount of cash Fannie is setting apart to cowl losses. Fannie, which doesn’t originate loans however buys loans from personal lenders, put aside $752 million in 2024 to cowl mortgage losses, citing mortgage fraud as a key issue.
The conclusions landed amid important upheaval on the housing finance companies. In 2025, FHFA Director Invoice Pulte named himself chairman of each Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac and eliminated 14 board members. Fannie’s CEO departed abruptly later that 12 months, and several other senior executives in its multifamily division have since exited, together with a former deputy general counsel concerned in overseeing fraud investigations.
Previous to the FHFA report, there had been few indications that multifamily mortgage fraud was easing. House house owners continued to wrestle in 2025 as increased rates of interest strained money flows, and lenders together with Walker & Dunlop and Retailers Financial institution of Indiana publicly disclosed fraud-related issues in earnings studies.
“The report makes it sound like multifamily fraud largely disappeared — and was largely an early-2020s challenge however I don’t suppose it merely went away,” mentioned Joseph Kahn of VisionRE, an actual property advisory agency. “Extra seemingly, tighter company scrutiny pushed a lot of it into CMBS, and we’re seeing the implications as these loans bitter.”
Others echoed the sentiment. Christopher Whalen, chairman of Whalen International Advisors, which consults and analyzes monetary establishments, mentioned “Fraud is a unbroken drawback for each enterprises [Fannie and Freddie]. I believe it should go up in 2025-26.”
Whalen mentioned neither Fannie nor Freddie ought to be concerned within the multifamily house.
“They don’t have the individuals or sources to underwrite the credit score. Similar goes for HUD. As multifamily belongings sink additional in high quality, this turns into the brand new subprime asset class.”
After the Covid-19 pandemic, Fannie, Freddie Mac and the FHFA found an growing quantity of mortgage fraud the place debtors both inflated rent rolls or flipped properties to associated events. The aim was to safe loans bigger than they in any other case would have obtained. The investigations have led to Fannie and Freddie blacklisting dozens of business gamers, together with title companies, brokers, debtors and attorneys together with responsible pleas and felony costs.
The FHFA’s report additionally revealed the findings of one among Fannie’s first fraud investigations. In November 2023, Fannie suspended doing new enterprise with an unnamed mortgage brokerage. Fannie reviewed 126 high-risk loans on the brokerage. It employed outdoors counsel and accountants and located seven loans with “confirmed indicators of fraud,” based on the FHFA report.
Whereas the brokerage was not recognized, Meridian Capital was blacklisted by the companies across the identical time. Meridian was faraway from the company’s blacklist in 2025. Meridian didn’t return a request to remark.
From there, the company obtained extra tips on multifamily fraud, most submitted internally. Fannie mentioned nearly all of the guidelines led to investigations which had been closed with “no fraud discovered.”
However Fannie reported an enormous uptick in ideas and investigations in 2024. The inflow prompted the company to report the rise in mortgage fraud referrals as an rising threat to Fannie Mae’s board of administrators.
Fannie mentioned, as of late, investigations into mortgage fraud began to say no.
Fraud was not listed as a significant factor in its allowance for multifamily mortgage losses in Fannie’s most up-to-date report with the Securities and Change Fee.
Fannie has made inner modifications to forestall mortgage fraud. It mentioned it elevated necessities for value determinations and employed extra workers to assessment value determinations and property circumstances.
The company has additionally taken additional motion in opposition to sure lenders the place mortgage fraud was found.
Fannie required three lenders to repurchase 5 loans. Fannie has kicked eight lenders off its preferential delegation, which implies they must go extra hurdles to originate Fannie loans.
“Fannie Mae takes mortgage fraud very critically and we maintain accountable those that allow or take part in fraud schemes and different felony actions,” mentioned Fannie in a press release.
Learn extra
Meet the players tied to the big mortgage mess
Walker & Dunlop reports $100M exposure to mortgage fraud
Fannie Mae says it suffered losses from commercial mortgage fraud
